So...here's what I know.  If you want to order jewelry on line, Blue Nile is the place to go!  They have an amazing turn around time.  I ordered ring #2 on Thursday and it was delivered less than 24 hours after I placed my order.  The customer service at Blue Nile has been awesome.  I returned the first ring and they only charged me for the engraving.  We are very happy with the quality of the rings we have purchased from them.

I opened the box as soon as I got home from my work Christmas party.  I couldn't wait to see the inscription.  I was very happy to discover that it was much easier to read with the new lettering.  When Matt came home Friday night from playing cards, he tried it on.  It is still a little big.  However, after a long discussion, we decided to keep it.  His knuckles are much larger than the base of his hand.  He needs to be able to get it over his knuckle.  So...it's not perfect, but it's the best we can do unless we can find a wedding ring with a hinge!